American Exceptionalism and the Benefits of Statehood: An Analysis of the Growth Effects of Joining the United States of America* Robbert Maseland University of Groningen Rok Spruk University of Ljubljana

American Exceptionalism and the Benefits of Statehood: An Analysis of the Growth Effects of Joining the United States of America* Robbert Maseland University of Groningen Rok Spruk University of Ljubljana

Estudio Académico del 28 de enero de 2020 sobre el Desarrollo Económico y Beneficios de la Estadidad: análisis comparativo de Crecimiento entre los Territorios que se incorporaron como Estados y las Posesiones, como Puerto Rico, Territorios que quedaron NO INCORPORADOs.
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3526844
American Exceptionalism and the Benefits of Statehood: An Analysis of the Growth Effects of Joining the United States of America
Robbert MaselandUniversity of Groningen
Rok SprukUniversity of Ljubljana – Faculty of Economics
Abstract
This paper quantifies the economic benefits of joining the United States. Adapting extant static synthetic control models into a dynamic model similar to Arellano and Bond (1991), we are able to construct the counterfactual growth paths of Texas, California, Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah, Wyoming and Nevada had they not joined the USA. We show that the real growth path outperforms the counterfactuals substantially in all cases. In the same way, we construct counterfactual growth paths of Puerto Rico, Cuba, the Philippines and Greenland in the scenario where they joined the USA at times in history where this might have been a (remote) possibility. We find counterfactual growth to be substantially higher than the actual growth. Having established the positive economic effects of US membership, we subsequently assess the sources of this added growth, distinguishing between a class of explanations related to internal market access and a class of explanations related to institutional quality. Using a large number of determinants of institutional quality, we find that the institutional quality of the USA as a whole matches the quality predicted for New England most closely. This suggests that upon accession, states imported the institutional quality of New England, which was typically superior to what they would have likely developed by themselves. We show that this institutional bonus accounts for the bulk of the growth benefits of US accession. Keywords: statehood, United States, economic growthJEL Classification: C33, C55, E02, N11, N12, O43
https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=296064003086023020025120065006004023051084051044068022009100078027119024065117103025061001111055010001121125028024029017097113126046036051078023073123068073005125105004030032090001078065114102091113076070092114028027086115014076126070029118081095001122&EXT=pdf

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=4162e8b4f3&attid=0.1&permmsgid=msg-f:1670851157791478985&th=17300e4684b614c9&view=att&disp=inline